Why Saying 'Mukha Siyang Probinsyana' Is Problematic

Judging a person based on their looks is always problematic.
by Lynn Lopez   |  May 6, 2017
Image: ABS-CBN
Share This!

Earlier this week, before Senator Tito Sotto opened his mouth and proved yet again, among other things, his sexism, lack of sensitivity, and deplorable sense of humor (he claimed he was just joking in the face of all the backlash, but we're not laughing), Tim Yap was being roasted on social media for his tweet during the recently concluded Binibining Pilipinas competition, in which he said, "Some of the girls don't look like the provinces they represent."

Immediately, people chimed in with their humorous takes on what candidates from certain provinces should look like, effectively calling the events host out for his comment.

Featured Video


Tim Yap has since deleted his tweet and apologized, saying, "I think everyone is beautiful no matter where they're from." It's a fair sentiment, and he must be feeling somewhat relieved that some of the heat has been taken off him, given the still-raging firestorm surrounding Senator Sotto's comment.


But the incident should force us to take a hard look at our preconceived notions about what people should look like. No one seems to be scrutinizing the possibility that what the tweet essentially meant was that the women did not look like what people think of as typical probinsiyanas and could even be an act of discrimination and classism.

Unfortunately, there are still people who have their own ideas about what women from the provinces are like—at some point, any one of us has heard someone say something like, "Mukha siyang probinsiyana" and not always in a flattering way—so anything that goes against that image comes as a total surprise to them. Never mind the fact that Filipinos have wildly different features and you won't even know where anyone is actually from unless they tell you themselves.


What does it even mean to look like you come from a certain province when families come from all over and you couldn't really tell where people are from just by looking at them?

Judging one another based on whether their appearance conforms to our own ideas and expectations (and personal biases) is commonplace. It is not unheard of for people to criticize a woman's looks by describing her as "mukhang katulong," a problematic comment on many levels, because it not only favors one type of appearance while disparaging another, but is also contemptuous of the idea of being a household helper and makes it sound as if those who are employed as such are less worthwhile.


There are women who are described as "mukhang cheap" (and subsequently judged and shamed) for looking and dressing up a particular way, even if they're simply dressed in a way that makes them feel comfortable and attractive. Some people are surprised when a person is smarter than they thought she was just because she doesn't fit the stereotype of what a "smart" person should look like.


Commenting on people's facial features, body, and clothes is already a problem, but making assumptions about people's personality, character, and background based on how we judge their appearance takes it one step further.

If we think someone looks "cheap," "malandi," "mayabang," or whatever without actually interacting with them, then the people whose appearances we criticize are not the problem. The problem lies with us and our personal biases, which force us to assume we already know what they are like, or worse, judge them for what we think they are.

Got thoughts on the matter? Share your comments below or tweet us @candymagdotcom! We always love hearing from you.

How do you feel about this article?
About the author
Lynn Lopez
How do you feel?
Click on your mood to read related stories