What Happens When a Lead Star Leaves the TV Show?

The show must go on, as they say.
by Dyan Zarzuela   |  Oct 22, 2015
Share This!

Nina Dobrev as Elena Gilbert

People always leave, One Tree Hill's angsty Peyton Sawyer once said, but what happens when said people carry the weight of a TV show on their shoulders? When a lead actor or actress leaves, the show must go on, but things will never be the same again. Just look at what happened to OTH when Peyton and Lucas left town and lived happily ever after. Here are a few more examples of the show continuing despite the lead star leaving for good or just temporarily.

 1  Elena Gilbert from The Vampire Diaries

Nina Dobrev as Elena Gilbertvia ayeitstonia.tumblr.com


When it was first announced that Nina Dobrev was leaving the show, we couldn’t imagine a TVD without Elena, Katherine, and all the other characters Nina played. Now that the show is back, we see that it’s using this opportunity to put the spotlight on other characters and introduce a bunch of new villains, while staying true to its roots by bringing back the journal writing from season one. Since Elena was not killed off and is basically a sleeping beauty at the moment, we have a feeling she’ll be back for the series finale, but for now the show is making the most of her absence.

Featured Video

 2  Allison Argent from Teen Wolf

Allison Argent from Teen Wolf
via ungifable.tumblr.com


The hunter's death was a shocker and caused a major ripple effect on the show. If you're wondering why the showrunners didn't just make up some reason for her absence to leave the door open for a return, it was because they thought she wouldn't be "the kind of person who would just say, 'Okay, guys, I'm out of here. Take care.'" Allison is the kind of person who would die fighting for her friends—and in the end, that's exactly what happened. </3

 3  King Francis from Reign

King Francis from Reign
via xfrarytalex.tumblr.com


The producers have been open about the young king's eventual demise, which is not necessarily a spoiler if you know your French history—or at least Wiki-ed the real people that the characters are based on. But don't worry, they promise to give his death justice and take you on an "emotional journey." The showrunner says, "It’s going to be full of twists and turns, but it is going to be a weeper of epic proportions."

 4  Finn Hudson from Glee

Finn Hudson from Glee
via arcticxs.tumblr.com


Speaking of weepers of epic proportions, we could not stop ugly crying when Glee said goodbye to its quarterback, who passed away in real life too. It was a beautiful, cathartic episode, one of the best hours of the show—if not the best. Rest in peace, Finn and Cory.

 5  Ned Stark from Game of Thrones

Ned Stark from Game of Thrones
via the-madqueen.tumblr.com


These days it's almost expected for the show to kill off major characters, but back in season one, the world couldn't believe it when the honest, courageous Stark patriarch was cruelly beheaded. Even book readers who saw it coming couldn't help but feel all the feels. It's one thing to read about it, and another to see it happening. Ned's death proved that no character is safe and that anything could happen, which is one of the many reasons why the show is such a global hit.

 6  Jessica Day from New Girl

Jessica Day from New Girl
via bbonniecclyde.tumblr.com


Nobody panic—Jess is only on jury duty (while actress Zooey Deschanel is on maternity leave) and will be back for sure. Megan Fox will be the newer girl, playing a pharmaceutical sales rep who rents out Jess's room. We'll see how she changes the dynamics of the group when New Girl returns in January. 

 7  Derek Shepherd from Grey's Anatomy

Derek Shepherd from Grey's Anatomy
via fournormalguyswithanabnormaljob.tumblr.com


As a hospital drama, Grey's Anatomy has lost a few major characters, but McDreamy's death hit us the hardest. Showrunner Shonda Rhimes explains their decision to kill off the fan favorite and not have him skip town or something: "Meredith and Derek's love had to remain Meredith and Derek's love. So as painful as that was for me as a storyteller, the only way to preserve what felt true to me was that Derek was going to have to die in order for that to remain honest."

 8  The first Doctor from Doctor Who

The first Doctor from Doctor Who
via milesandinterstates.tumblr.com


When your show is called Doctor Who and the Doctor can no longer play the part because of poor health, do you call it quits? Or do you take it as an opportunity to introduce the concept of regeneration, which will allow the show to continue for as long as possible? William Hartnell was the first to play the time lord, and now we're on our Twelfth Doctor and have passed the 50th anniversary mark. The show must go on, and this one seems it'll go on forever, much to the delight of Whovians.

How do you feel about this article?
About the author
Dyan Zarzuela
Council of Cool 9, Managing Editor, Columnist
Stalks celebrities, watches TV, marathons movies, curls up with books, and flails at concerts for a living. Also: semi-hardcore Whovian.
How do you feel?
Click on your mood to read related stories